Rhett asks: I need to start 2 running backs from this group – L.T., Brandon Jacobs, Kevin Jones; and 3 receivers from this group – Chad Johnson, Roddy White, Amoni Toomer, Bobby Engram. Which ones should I start?
Brandon’s take: Although on paper, Kevin Jones has a better matchup, I actually think Jacobs will have a solid game this week. Also, consider that in the past four games, Jacobs is averaging about 25 yards/game better than Jones. Obviously you’re never going to bench LT, so go with LT and Jacobs. In terms of receivers though, you have more of a dilemma, unless Chad Johnson doesn’t play this week. IF he plays (he’s questionable now), then you have to start him and I’d recommend benching Roddy White (who was mediocre last week against a mediocre defense). I think Chad Johnson might not play though, making your decision a lot easier.
Matt’s take: I’m with Brandon on the receivers. As for Jacobs vs. Jones, it’s close, and either of them could be in for a big day. But I’m going to beg to differ with Brandon on this one and suggest that you start Jones. Dallas has allowed an average of only 84 rushing yards per game, and has given up only four rushing touchdowns; compare that to 115 and seven for Arizona. In addition, think about how those two games are likely to play out. Detroit’s defense has been solid, and they’re the favorite to beat the Cards – which means they’re likely to be holding a lead for most of the game. That also means they’re likely to run the ball a lot. Compare that to the Giants-Cowboys matchup, which seems more likely to be a shootout, so Jacobs might not see a whole ton of carries. Dallas is much more vulnerable through the air than on the ground, so I expect to see a lot of Eli Manning, and not so much of Brandon Jacobs. With all that said, Jacobs is a beast, so I can’t blame you if you start him, but I’d go with Jones.
(More …)